Fresh from our Bakery

We're ready to serve you
We're ready to serve you

Delicious Pies
Delicious Pies

Homemade Key Lime Pie
Homemade Key Lime Pie

We're ready to serve you
We're ready to serve you

1/6

Bakery

All of our baked goods are made and baked on premises daily. Ask your server about availability.

Fresh Baked Whole Pies

Our delicious pies are made fresh daily. Pies are available for order online and in our bakery based on current availability. Orders placed by 12pm can be filled for the same day. To guarantee your favorite pie is available when you want it, pre order it by 7pm and it will be ready the following day after by 10am. Please contact us at info@gourmetpieandcafe.com for order ready timing for orders of 20 or more pies.

Apple Double Crust Pie

11.95

Banana Cream Pie

12.95

Blueberry Crunch

12.45

Boysenberry Cream Cheese Pie

13.45

Boysenberry Double Crust Pie

11.95

Cherry Cream Cheese Pie

13.40

Chocolate Cream Pie

12.95

Coconut Cream Pie

12.95

Custard Pie

11.95

Key Lime Pie

12.95

Lemon Meringue Pie

11.95

Lemon Sour Cream Pie

12.95

Pumpkin Pie

11.95

Pecan Pie

13.95

Double Crust Cherry Pie

11.95

French Apple Pie

11.95

Double Crust Peach Pie

12.45

Strawberry Cream Cheese Pie

13.40

Peanut Butter Pie

12.95

Pre-Order Pies

The following pies must be pre ordered 48 hours in advance. · Cherry double crust · Custard Pie · Lemon Meringue Pie · Pecan Pie · Pumpkin Pie

Cake By The Slice

Carrot Cake

5.95

Chocolate Fudge

5.95

Cheesecake

4.95

Fresh Fruit Cheesecake

5.95

Chocolate Eclair

4.50

Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

3.95

Cookies & Breakfast Pastries

Check our bakery case or ask your server about our fresh made cookies and pastries of the day.

Please reload